Killing of Arab girl - Reader's Letter

February 03, 2005

 

The Independent reported, based on original Palestinian claims it never checked with the IDF, that a Palestinian girl Nuran Dib was killed by shrapnel fired from an IDF tank shell at an UNWRA schoolyard in Rafah, where Dib was playing. Now the Palestinians themselves arrested a Palestinian suspect in Monday's murder of Nuran Dib, on Tuesday evening. The man reportedly fired shots into the air; one of those shots hit the girl.

See an excellent short Reader's Letter on this:

 
From: Stuart Palmer
To: newseditor@independent.co.uk 
Sent: Thursday, February 03, 2005 9:30 AM

To: The Independent

Letter Editor Thursday, February 03, 2005

Sirs,

Now, as has happened so many times in past, we learn that the little girl was killed by a Palestinian, who was shooting into the air during a religious celebration. (See article below).

Are you going to publish an apology? I dare you!

Stuart Palmer

Haifa, Israel
PA arrests suspect in girl's murder

Margot Dudkevitch, THE JERUSALEM POST
Feb. 1, 2005

The Palestinians arrested a suspect in Monday's murder of Nuran Dib, on Tuesday evening. The man reportedly fired shots into the air; one of those shots hit the girl. The suspect is being questioned regarding the shooting. The IDF said on Monday night that following an initial investigation, it did not seem that the 10-year-old from Rafah was hit by IDF tank fire.

Palestinians had originally claimed that the girl was killed by shrapnel fired from an IDF tank shell at an UNWRA schoolyard in Rafah, where Dib was playing.

The Palestinians used the supposed killing as a pretext to resume firing mortars at Gaza Strip settlements.

During the day Monday, soldiers positioned in posts located along the Philadelphi Route fired twice from light weapons into areas far from where the girl was hit, security officials said.

The officials said that at the time the girl was killed, officials at the District Coordinating Office received reports that in the same area Muslim worshippers returning from the Hajj in Mecca fired warning shots in the air to celebrate their return.
 

 
 

© www.take-a-pen.org